Old Time Pizza Menu (Update 2026)

Battered mushrooms are perfect for an appetizer or a delicious snack! Served with ranch dipping sauce

Breaded Oval Zucchini Slices make for flavorful appetizers in minutes. These tender oval-cut zucchini slices come with an Italian-style cheese and bread crumb coating for a delicious golden-brown crispy texture. Served with ranch dipping sauce.

Fried pickles are made with crisp pickles and a lightly seasoned breading for a perfectly delicious treat for your taste buds! Served with ranch dressing.

Munchers are a blend of diced potatoes, green chile peppers, and cheddar cheese. These cheese bites are flavorful with a crispy texture on the outside. Served with ranch dipping sauce.

Philly cheese steak made with onion, mushrooms, green bell peppers, cheese, mayonnaise and mustard on a toasted 8" sub roll. Served with pickle, pepperoncini, and chips. The Beef philly is our most popular sandwich!

Ham and cheese sandwich on an 8" sub roll. Made hot or cold with mayonnaise, mustard, cheese, lettuce, and tomato. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Sliced turkey on an 8" sub roll. Made hot or cold with mayonnaise, mustard, cheese, lettuce and tomato. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Sliced roast beef on an 8" sub roll. Made hot or cold with mayonnaise, mustard, cheese, lettuce and tomato. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Sliced pastrami on an 8" sub roll. Made hot or cold with mayonnaise, mustard, cheese, lettuce and tomato. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Delicious sliced roast beef on an 8" golden toasted bun perfect for dipping. Cheese optional at no extra cost. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, chips, and Au Jus sauce.

Seasoned meatballs, marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese, onion, mushrooms, and bell peppers toasted to perfection on an 8" sub bun. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Sliced salami, ham, and bologna made with cheese, mayonnaise, mustard, lettuce, and tomato. Your choice of hot or cold and served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Irresistible crispy chicken tenders on an 8" sub roll with mayonnaise, cheese, lettuce and tomato. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Crispy chicken tenders dipped in zesty wing sauce on an 8" sub roll with ranch dressing, cheese, and lettuce. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Grilled chicken paired with onions, bell peppers, pineapple, mayonnaise, and cheese on an 8 " sub roll. Served hot with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Gourmet fried catfish on a toasted 8" sub roll with mayonnaise, tartar sauce, American cheese, and lettuce. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Philly cheese steak made with onion, mushrooms, green bell peppers, cheese, mayonnaise and mustard on a toasted 8" sub roll. Served with pickle, pepperoncini, and chips. The Beef philly is our most popular sandwich!

Ham and cheese sandwich on an 8" sub roll. Made hot or cold with mayonnaise, mustard, cheese, lettuce, and tomato. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Sliced turkey on an 8" sub roll. Made hot or cold with mayonnaise, mustard, cheese, lettuce and tomato. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Sliced roast beef on an 8" sub roll. Made hot or cold with mayonnaise, mustard, cheese, lettuce and tomato. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Sliced pastrami on an 8" sub roll. Made hot or cold with mayonnaise, mustard, cheese, lettuce and tomato. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Delicious sliced roast beef on an 8" golden toasted bun perfect for dipping. Cheese optional at no extra cost. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, chips, and Au Jus sauce.

Seasoned meatballs, marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese, onion, mushrooms, and bell peppers toasted to perfection on an 8" sub bun. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Sliced salami, ham, and bologna made with cheese, mayonnaise, mustard, lettuce, and tomato. Your choice of hot or cold and served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Irresistible crispy chicken tenders on an 8" sub roll with mayonnaise, cheese, lettuce and tomato. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Crispy chicken tenders dipped in zesty wing sauce on an 8" sub roll with ranch dressing, cheese, and lettuce. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Grilled chicken paired with onions, bell peppers, pineapple, mayonnaise, and cheese on an 8 " sub roll. Served hot with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.

Gourmet fried catfish on a toasted 8" sub roll with mayonnaise, tartar sauce, American cheese, and lettuce. Served with a pickle, pepperoncini, and bag of chips.